
A married couple from the Memphis area came to Damiens Law Firm after the IRS billed them for tax that had already been taken out of one spouse’s paychecks. The employer had kept the money. About a year later the IRS reversed the assessment, released the refunds it had been holding, and removed the penalties.
Key takeaways
- An employer withheld tax from paychecks but never paid it to the IRS.
- The IRS billed the employee and kept two years of refunds.
- Pay stubs and an audit reconsideration reversed the assessment.
- A collection hearing request kept the levy on hold while the case was decided.
What happened
One spouse worked for a small employer that withheld federal income tax and Social Security tax from every paycheck. The employer never sent the money to the IRS and never filed W-2s. Because the IRS had no record of the withholding, it treated the tax as unpaid and assessed it against the employee.
The IRS then kept the couple’s refunds for two later years and applied them to the disputed balance. A CP504 notice followed, warning that the IRS intended to levy.
What they had already tried
The couple had written to the IRS themselves to appeal. The letter went to the wrong office and was never worked, and collection kept moving.
What we did
- Filed a power of attorney and pulled the IRS account records for every year involved.
- Confirmed the assessment came from missing W-2 information, not from anything the couple failed to report.
- Submitted an audit reconsideration with pay stubs showing the tax had been withheld.
- Requested a Collection Due Process hearing, which put the levy on hold while the case was decided.
- Worked the case with the IRS Office of Appeals.
The result
The IRS accepted that the tax had been withheld from the employee’s pay. It reversed the assessment, approved the claim for refund, released the held refunds with interest, and removed the penalties. No levy was issued and no lien was filed.
What Memphis-area workers should know
- If your employer took tax out of your pay, keep your pay stubs. They are the proof when the employer’s filings are missing.
- The IRS will not fix this on its own because you tell it the employer was at fault. It takes a documented request sent to the right unit.
- The deadline to request a collection hearing is short. Missing it gives up the best tool for stopping a levy.
Talk to a Memphis tax attorney
Damiens Law Firm represents taxpayers across the Memphis area from its office at 1331 Union Avenue, Suite 918, Memphis, TN 38104. If you have received an IRS notice, call 601-957-9672 for a free consultation with Joseph Damiens, Esq., J.D., LL.M. (Taxation).
Related: Memphis IRS audit attorney | Tax audit defense | Memphis tax attorney
Client details are withheld or generalized to protect confidentiality. Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome.